Continue reading
In the summer of 2007, BlackBerry cofounder Mike Lazaridis took apart an iPhone. “They’ve put a Mac in this thing,” he said. He recognized that Apple was changing the competition. He also believed BlackBerry’s corporate business was protected by its keyboard and secure email. Apple could win consumers; BlackBerry would keep business.
The trouble was that those were often the same people. Someone who loved using an iPhone at home wanted to use it at work, and employers increasingly allowed it. BlackBerry’s assumptions about who chose the phone, and why, were coming apart. Its share of U.S. smartphone shipments fell from 46 percent in 2008 to 2 percent in 2012.
Lazaridis could take apart the competing product and understand what made it work. Taking apart the beliefs behind his own company’s success proved considerably harder.
Strategy is an intentional response to a worthy challenge that stands in the way of mission success.
BlackBerry’s competencies and capabilities could contribute to that response, just as its aspirations, goals, values, and vision statements could inform it. But none could substitute for framing the right challenges, designing coherent responses, and testing the assumptions supporting them.
Management can do no greater harm than to find the right answer to the wrong question. BlackBerry could engineer a better keyboard and still lose business customers who wanted a phone that did more. Framing the central challenge required understanding how those customers’ expectations were changing and how much influence they were gaining over the purchasing decision. Treating Apple’s arrival as a typing problem invited the company to keep answering the wrong question. The better question was how BlackBerry would remain the preferred choice of business customers as more powerful phones entered the market.
Designing the response meant confronting several connected challenges. Corporate relationships were becoming less effective at protecting accounts, established advantages were losing their hold on customer preferences, and maintaining the existing business competed for the resources needed to change it. BlackBerry needed to decide how to earn the loyalty of both corporate buyers and employees, how to sustain revenue during the transition, and which existing commitments would have to take a backseat. Coherence meant ensuring those responses reinforced one another, so efforts to protect the current business did not prevent the changes needed to move it forward.
Those choices would still depend on assumptions that leaders needed to keep testing. Would corporate buyers continue to control the purchasing decision? Would employees choose BlackBerry when given an alternative? How long would existing customers stay while the company developed a more competitive offering? Customer trials, observation of purchasing behavior, and patterns in lost accounts could have helped answer those questions. Revisiting them as evidence accumulated could have prompted adjustments while BlackBerry still had the customers, revenue, and time to make them.
Apple put BlackBerry’s assumptions to the test by giving customers compelling reasons to choose differently. Its strategy changed what people expected from a phone and weakened the protection BlackBerry believed its corporate relationships provided. If you don’t actively test the assumptions behind your strategy, your competitors will do it for you, at your expense.
