Implications for developing better strategy

Continue reading

Enter your email to access this article and all future S2A insights.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

We start by viewing the role of strategy from a system dynamics perspective.

An advantage in doing so is that the ideal target and process become simple and obvious.  

Our core beliefs around core principles mirror those Richard Rumelt describes in Good Strategy Bad Strategy.

The ideal target is most critical solvable problem, where achieving the result would make the most other good things happen or become much easier to accomplish

The most reliable process for getting there is a funnel that Rumelt calls the kernel of good strategy.  The three elements are diagnosis, guiding principles and coherent actions.

What we find is that when leaders follow this approach reasonably well, they get the best of both worlds.  Formal strategy provides alignment while emergent strategy improves adaptation.  

< Link to Brad’s review of Good Strategy Bad Strategy>

<Links to other pieces?>

‍

We also observe what happens in organizations when leaders deviate from these principles.  The more uncertain and turbulent the conditions, the more they deviate, the more anxiety tends to rise.

The trap to avoid is falling into a pattern where important decisions on strategy don’t get made in a timely fashion.  Plans, budgets and goals are all important, but none of these fills the role of good strategy.

What happens is people find themselves relying on unreliable assumptions and luck.  Alignment gets spotty and results suffer.  When the pattern continues, finger pointing breaks out.  This is a reliable symptom of bad strategy.

The process through which organizations choose to create their strategy also influences where decisions get made.  

When principles aren’t followed, people end up deferring to whatever the highest-ranking people say the “strategy” means.  

Karl Weick’s analogy with umpires who “call them like they see them” helps explain the logic.  What determines the difference between a ball and a strike isn’t an objective truth.  It all comes down to how the umpire sees it.  By design the umpire has decision rights.  Players can only defer to the umpires’ perception or leave, voluntarily or by ejection.  

In leading an organization, keeping your eye on the ball is far more complicated than in a baseball game.  There are always lots of balls in the air.  And plenty of uncertainty around which matter most.  Someone has to make the most important calls.  But do you really want to be responsible for calling every pitch?  What about all those that turn out to be important and fall through the cracks?  

As uncertainty and turbulence increase, the challenge heats up.  With AI, it’s plenty challenging.

This is where good process comes in.  Leaders who direct focus to diagnosis, guiding principles and coherent actions change the nature of the conversation.   Decisions on which pitch to watch and how to respond become distributed.  Good strategy ensures people operate with a clear shared reference point.  Running through the chain from diagnosis to guiding principles to action, shapes the distributional logic.

One important benefit is better information where you need it most.  Another is the motivational benefits of commitment that comes when people play a role in shaping strategy in the areas where they have the most knowledge and expertise.  All of that follows from how you develop your strategy and what you put into it.

That’s the rationale in a nutshell behind a preferred logic for developing strategy and why it leads to different patterns of decision making.

Simple, though not easy to do consistently well.

For examples of where we’ve seen organizations following a similar approach and the results see the other pieces in this issue.

‍

Read More

You May Also Be Interested In:

Bradley Brezinski

What BlackBerry Forgot to Take Apart

Nat Bulkey

Rallying Around a Disruptive Threat

Heading