Rallying Around a Disruptive Threat: How starting with diagnosis changes how strategy gets made

When precision medicine disrupted pharma R&D, IT leaders started with diagnosis instead of a budget pitch, and strategy became shared work across functions.

Rallying Around a Disruptive Threat: How starting with diagnosis changes how strategy gets made

Never let a good crisis go to waste can be a useful adage. How do you apply it when facing a challenge that represents a disruptive threat to how work has always been done?

Early in my career, I participated in an example that has stuck with me. For R&D and IT in the pharmaceutical industry, the rise of precision medicine was a game changer.

Before precision medicine technologies began to mature, data reuse was an afterthought. Then advances in genetics demonstrated that when clinical trials wash out in the most expensive later stages, the reason is often that a treatment is effective in some subpopulations and not others.

Technology opened the door to recovering significant proportions of otherwise lost R&D investments by identifying the subpopulations where a drug works. It also accelerated the shift towards reducing R&D costs through simulations.

Big pharma companies were sitting on a gold mine of data. What lacked was the technical and social infrastructure to enable the right people to find the right data in a timely manner.

IT leaders could have glossed this over, throwing around jargon and playing to fears of falling behind in hopes of securing as much budget as possible. Instead, they took the concept of understanding the challenge seriously and started ferreting out implications.

Learning that more than two-thirds of researchers considered finding the right data difficult validated the problem. They also learned their current investments were doing little to help. By a more than 3 to 1 margin, respondents said they found ad hoc conversations with colleagues more useful for finding the right data than any of the IT systems or business partners.

Drawing attention to the social aspects of what had been seen as an almost exclusively technical problem prompted a shift in direction. When they mapped connections between human sources recognized as the most useful, the picture resembled a scattering of islands accompanied by one long snake. If anyone had set out to design a less efficient structure to support the direction in which work was evolving, they would have been hard pressed to do so.

That structure was nobody’s fault. It had arisen organically. It worked fine under earlier conditions, so nobody noticed. However, it posed a serious liability for where things were going.

Resisting the pressure to immediately jump in with a solution, leaders used what they’d learned to engage people on the technological front lines. Reaching out and weaving together a clear picture takes an intentional process and time. They made the investment. The result of bringing the most relevant knowledge to the table was a solid diagnosis accompanied by scenarios that provided a foundation for developing guiding principles and coordinated actions.

The moment of truth arrived in the first meeting between top IT and R&D executives. The candid response that came back was “for the first time, we really understand what you all do!”

Instead of relying on overly hopeful or fearful assumptions, both sides now saw primary issues clearly. Common ground based on actual conditions informed guiding policies and actions. The process had also engaged front line technology leaders in thinking through implications, which served them well for adapting to shifts in priorities.

Challenging financial and organizational issues still had to be worked through. What changed reflected the confidence and motivation that comes from involving people when their efforts can make a difference as opposed to inflicting consequences of untested assumptions on them later. All of this work laid a foundation for what today is a leading position in the industry.

Good strategy reflects the response to a challenge. When decision makers lack the context for understanding the challenge, bad strategy tends to follow.

Never let a good crisis go to waste can be a helpful mantra for companies facing disruptive threats. The key lies in how you decide to put the challenge to good use.

Nat Bulkey
Nat Bulkey
is senior advisor for organizational intelligence at S2A, where he helps organizations improve how people, culture, and strategy work together.

Read next from The Strategist

All articles →